Sunday, March 11, 2012

A Vote For Romney Is A Vote For Obama

Recently, a friend statused the following on Facebook:
Remember during the election for pres on nov 12 a vote for Ron Paul is a vote for Obama. I think Ron will be voting for the republican candidate himself because he does not like Obama either. I am just saying make ur vote count and don't pencil in Ron Paul and waste a vote to get Obama out of office.
My response to this status turned into my previous post on how the GOP can't win without a Ron Paul nomination. My conclusion:  "If, on election day, Ron Paul has to be written onto the ballot by voters then the GOP has already lost." Furthermore, a vote for Mitt Romney IS a vote for Barack Obama. 


Many people are under the illusion that Mitt Romney has the best chance to beat Obama. If you believe the latest Rasmussen poll, 51% of Republicans think that Romney is the best bet for beating Obama. There are plenty of lies, damned lies and statistics in this report, but that's no surprise. What is noteworthy, however, is that 56% of Republicans think "best chance to beat Obama" is the most important factor. The correlation between people who think "best chance to beat Obama" is the most important thing and people who think Romney has the best chance confirms what I said previously: "The only positive trait that Mitt Romney has is that it is believed he can beat Obama." This belief is purely a statement of faith though. It is devoid of any knowledge of history. And as if to prove the old saying, the GOP is hellbent on repeating history. Mitt Romney is just the next candidate in the growing line of moderate, neo-Conservative Republican losers. 


In 1992, George H. W. Bush was the first of the modern moderate neocon losers. Sure, he talked "family values" but everyone knew from his record that he wasn't actually socially conservative. During his Vice-Presidency, and before, he was pro-choice, and his fiscal policies were moderate, at best. He won in 1988 on the momentum, albeit fading, of the Reagan Revolution and because he was running against a Massachusetts Governor named Romney Dukakis. But during that campaign, Bush famously promised "Read my lips: No New Taxes." But his moderate core got the best of him, and during his first term he raised taxes. Not only that, he introduced the whole globalist concept of a New World Order and signed NAFTA. No amount of family values could save him once his true moderate neocon side had been revealed. 


In 1996, Bob Dole was the next moderate trotted out. Only this time he was running against an incumbent Democrat who had a mildly rocky first term and whose party lost big in the mid-term elections. That doesn't sound familiar at all. Bob Dole inspired zero enthusiasm in the Republican party getting 22% fewer votes than George W. Bush did 4 years later. The Dole nomination, like the Romney candidacy, had an air of inevitability to it, as if it was finally his turn. Nobody was excited by him.  But Dole's claim was that he had the best chance to beat Clinton. Here is some news coverage from the time:
"The results boosted Dole's claim that he has the best chance to beat Clinton as 3,400 delegates and hordes of national media prepared to gather in Orlando this weekend for Presidency III, the Florida Republican straw poll."
And the GOP voters fell for it. Dole lost by almost 10% in the popular vote and 40% in the electoral vote. It was a resounding defeat.

The GOP changed their strategy somewhat in 2000 and ran on a far less moderate, less neocon platform. George W. Bush promoted a "humble foreign policy", a pro-life agenda, reduction in the size of government, across the board tax cuts and so on. And while it was a close race, he ultimately prevailed. Unfortunately he turned out to be one of the biggest spending, big government, military adventurists of a generation after 9/11. During his administration, the neocons became the dominant force in the Republican party. Their rise to power culminated in the nomination of John McCain in 2008.

I don't need to spend much time on McCain. Most people can remember back 4 years and the dismal failure that was McCain-Palin. The bottom line is that he was very moderate, very "electable" and he lost by 10,000,000 votes to Barack Obama. The worst defeat in electoral votes by any presidential candidate (including a politician from Massachusetts named Romney Kerry) since Bob Dole's humiliating defeat.

So back to the Facebook status at the top. The message is that if Ron Paul is written in on a ballot, it is a vote for Obama. The exact opposite is true. Writing in a vote for Ron Paul, if it comes to that, is a vote against Obama. It's also a vote against the moderate, neo-Conservative candidates that the GOP keeps trying to push forward that can't win. In the last 20 years, they've proven time and time again, that going with the moderate, the guy with the perceived Best Chance to Beat the incumbent democrat or the guy who whose turn has finally come is the way to lose. But somehow we are supposed to believe that this time is different. It's not. A vote for Mitt Romney is a vote for Barack Obama.

-Addendum: I didn't talk about Ross Perot (what is it with Texans bearing the initials RP?). But in the case of the Dole defeat, you could move every single vote for Perot over to Dole and he still would have lost the popular election and the electoral vote. In the 1992 race, Perot likely did change the outcome. However, his biggest issue, NAFTA, captured a lot of typically Democrat union votes, so it isn't totally clear that Bush would have won. You could make an argument that Perot could have defeated Clinton if he had been the GOP nominee. But with Bush being the incumbent and pushing Perot to a third party, he didn't stand a chance for victory. Paul is not going third party and there isn't an incumbent Republican. So, I would argue that a Romney nomination splits the vote that would otherwise go to Paul.

    Thursday, March 8, 2012

    Why The GOP Can't Win (and how it will lose BIG) Without A Ron Paul Nomination


    If the GOP nominates a candidate other than Ron Paul, Obama is guaranteed a second term.

    Neither Mitt, Rick or Newt can beat Obama and this is nearly indisputable. Newt needs no explanation: he is absolutely unelectable. He hasn't had a good showing except his home state of Georgia and its neighbor South Carolina. He is only getting weaker with each state and is not a serious candidate, no matter how good a debater his followers imagine him to be. Santorum cannot beat Obama as shown in every national poll and by the fact that he alienates every single voting bloc of the Republican coalition except for the religious right/Christian conservatives. And while they may have admirable aims, they do not represent a bloc of voters that can win an election. If they did, Pat Robertson would have been President already. Mitt Romney inspires absolutely zero enthusiasm in the Republican base or in any of its composite blocs except for the country club/wall street Republicans. But it is precisely their enthusiasm that makes every other segment of the Republican party feel blasé about him. The only positive trait that Mitt Romney has is that it is believed he can beat Obama. This is wrong. In fact, take away "Mitt can beat Obama" and what do his supporters have? Nothing.

    Ron Paul, on the other hand, has an enthusiastic, energetic and very importantly, young following that would walk across burning shards of glass for their candidate. The vast majority of these supporters are Republicans. But whereas the other candidates are ONLY attractive to one segment of one party, Ron Paul attracts the following non-traditional GOP voters: civil libertarians who might typically vote democrat but refuse to support Obama because he signed the NDAA (and note only Ron Paul in the GOP race opposed it on its indefinite detention grounds); independent non-party followers who tend to be less conservative but view Obama as no better than any of the GOP candidates and view Paul as a party outsider who speaks to their concerns; the anti-war movement types who are typically democrat but again see no difference between Obama and the rest. But Paul's main foreign policy message of "bring our troops home" resonates with them; disaffected democrats that don't fall in any particular group but feel that Obama is a failure for not following through on campaign promises to: 1) close gitmo 2) prosecute wall street 3) end bush tax cuts 4) change the tone in Washington (hope and change!) and so on. There are many democrats who feel sold out by Obama for his cozy (crony) relationship with Wall Street and his continuation of Bush's foreign policy and domestic fiscal policy. These people will never consider any of the other 3 GOP candidates because what they hate about Obama is his similarity to Republicans. 

    However, Ron Paul is not similar to any of them. He actually does represent hope and change and will create a whole new generation of what used to be called Reagan Democrats who defected to Reagan after the abysmal Carter administration. But this is a double-edged sword. The GOP has a chance to establish its base for the next 20+ years by embracing a Ron Paul candidacy or it will lose a generation of voters to the Democrat party. Those young, enthusiastic and energetic Paul supporters were in large part Obama supporters 4 years ago. Paul is the only chance to bring them into the GOP tent and deprive the Democrats of their numbers for years to come. But if the GOP stubbornly sticks to its marginalizing  tactics and dismisses these voters they will likely swear off the GOP for life. The GOP will then face its own extinction since its current base is quickly aging and dying off. 

    I would be remiss if I didn't mention that it isn't just the "blue democrats" or independents that make up the Ron Paul support base. It's also lifelong Republicans (like myself) who are completely disenchanted with a party that massively grew the size of government for the 6 years they controlled all branches. The "small government" party that added Medicare Part D, grew the size of the Department of Education, created the monstrous Department of Homeland Security and the anti-Constitution Patriot Act. The "free market" party that bailed out the Too Big to Fail banks, bailed out the auto industry and "abandoned the free-market system" (to “save” it) as George W Bush said in 2008. For those of us Republicans who believe in a limited role for Government and free market principles, we see in Ron Paul a return to the values of Republicanism that made this country the shining city on a hill that Reagan spoke of. And for those who would say Reagan's values were "family values",  you must understand that the term didn't even rise to prominence until the second campaign of George HW Bush in 1992. The platform that Reagan ran on is more closely aligned to Ron Paul than any other candidate. 

    To paraphrase a quote: Republicans have been subnormal for so long that when they finally act normal, people think they are abnormal. Ron Paul is a normal Republican. The GOP can't win without Ron Paul's supporters and it can't survive if it shuts them out. If, on election day, Ron Paul has to be written onto the ballot by voters then the GOP has already lost.

    Tuesday, May 24, 2011

    Manufacturing Ain't Rosy

    Krugman's attempts to lipstick our current pig of an economy are way off mark recently. When he's not advocating for yet another disconnect between CPI and inflation (ie real prices paid by real people for real things), or saying there is no inflation due to no wage growth, he's been trying to paint some rosy picture of manufacturing's rebound in our "recovery". The reality is he's just running cover for his pals at the FED and the DNC.

    Krugman bases his ideas on what appears to be one rose-colored chart that he concocted... this one:

    The quote that immediately follows it: "The weaker dollar really has made a big difference." 


    Wait, what?


    Since he doesn't give much backing other than to talk about how he technically derived the data for the chart, I'm a little confused at what Krugman is seeing as "a picture of the recent improvement in the US manufacturing trade position." Is it that tiny uptick at the end of the chart from -2.4 to -2.0? Or is it that huge uptick beginning in Q406? And why is the weaker Dollar getting credit for a big difference? 

    The Dollars been getting weak for a long time. 



    2002-2005 was a period of severe weakening of the dollar - to the tune of 30% weakening, yet during that time, the manufacturing balances plunged. Since the momentary rise in 2005, the Dollar has weakened by about only 16% and QE2 has been about neutral on the Dollar despite the FED's efforts to debase it away. So what "big difference" are we seeing from a "weaker dollar"? 


    That's all really a sideshow, though, to the main thing Krugman is trying to do here. He takes whatever movement he's seeing in that manufacturing balance and makes a case that "America’s industrial heartland is now leading the economic recovery." And " the U.S. auto industry, which many people were writing off just two years ago, has weathered the storm."

    Ford Casting Plant - Cleveland Ohio (closed 12/2010)

    Ford Motor Plant - Detroit Michigan
    General Motors Plant - Muncie Indiana
    Some weathering. And how did the US auto industry come out so ahead in this game? Oh right... Government stimulus and bailout. 

    Now, Krugman has to be the only person in the world who sees anything positive in the manufacturing sector. Let's check:

    Wall Street Journal: US Stocks Pare Gains After Weak Manufacturing Data - May 19
    BusinessWeek: Industrial companies down on lower production data - May 17

    And now, this from today:
    Those worried about a slowdown probably focused Tuesday on a report by the Richmond Federal Reserve showing a decline in manufacturing activity in May. The Richmond Fed index fell to a negative 6 after a reading of 10 in April, as shipments and new orders declined.
    "When you combine this report with the Philadelphia Fed and New York Fed manufacturing reports, the odds are stacking up that we’re going to see some softening in the national ISM report that comes out on June 1," Sheldon said.
    Softening anyone?
    So two final things:
    Where did Krugman go wrong and why is he being so blatantly wrong?

    The first part takes a little critical thinking. The lower GDP we are experiencing led by lower consumption has meant some fewer imports. It's not that manufacturing is picking up and going great, it's that we just aren't consuming so voraciously now that our homes have become dwellings and not ATM's. So the trade imbalance is not so wildly out of whack. Therefore, the manufacturing balance is less negative than it has been.  Krugman's chart looks less correlated to the Dollar's strength then it does to the economies strength as a whole. This is very basic, but very bad, lying with charts.

    The second part (why is he doing this?) is easy. With a double-dip recession on the way (and in spades), Krugman is building his case for more fiscal stimulus and more bailouts. He'll point back to green shoots in manufacturing that came about by Government bailout and spending and weep that the Republicans killed it out of their sheer hatred for unions and "the little guy." We'll hear sighing and mumbling coming from the NY Times pages over how the recovery was just taking hold when it was destroyed by hostage taking congressmen. This also sets the stage to ravage the Dollar. If the weak Dollar has done these great things, what can we get with a weaker Dollar? 

    As currencies begin to devalue around the world, I can almost smell the hyperinflation.

    Thursday, May 19, 2011

    QOTD: "Ok, I'm a Nazi"

    You have to feel bad for Kirsten Dunst in this clip of Lars Von Trier declaring his affinity for Hitler and his own, sorta, Nazi status.

    I imagine Dunst is getting paid through some sort of knock on royalty for the film Melancholia. A film that we get to observe lose distributors in real time during this interview. Time to start shorting the odds that Dunst gets to play love interest for a super hero in America again.




    "Riefenstahl and Goebbels give it 2 Thumbs UP!"

    "Five Swastikas" - Der Stürmer

    "Von Trier's Triumph of the Will!" - Das Schwarze Korps


    The Paul Ryan Defense

    Many thanks go out to Representative Paul Ryan for giving everyone in America a valid excuse to be late on all debt payments.



    Me: Hello, Wells Fargo?
    WF: Yes, how can we service you?
    Me: I'm going to be late on a mortgage payment, but it's in order for me to get into a materially better position to pay the rest of mortgage. Cool?
    WF: Oh, absolutely!
    Me: I mean, you won't penalize me with any fees or record a late payment or anything right?
    WF: Oh, no. We just want what's best for you and are happy to accommodate whatever repayment works for you.

    Somehow, I don't think so.

    FICO Declares: We're Still Relevant, Really!

    The Austrians over at Mises are covering a MarketWatch story about the damage of strategic default to your Credit Score. There are so many layers of B.S. here I don't even know where to begin.

    I guess I'll start with the Fair-Issacs scaremonger warning everyone of the dangers of strategic default because of the credit score hit. The scary begins with a <gasp> 140 point drop in your score followed by a stern warning about how discriminating banks are these days.

    Fannie, please!

    Banks aren't discriminating. They just aren't lending. The halcyon days of securitizing unlimited loans are done. It's easier for banks to just keep money in their reserves and make interest, risk free, from the FED. Then there are the cherry fees they are collecting from distressed checking customers. They don't have to put anything at risk for those billions each year. The 720 or 580 credit score is irrelevant at this point. Everyone is too risky for a measly 3-4%. Fair-Issacs is trying to convince us that they matter. They need more $12/mo credit monitoring customers and $29.95 triple score buyers.

    It's a waste of time. The FICO is screwed because banks don't need to lookup and when you got choose between eating and paying the mortgage (let alone credit monitoring) - you are buying the food. Especially when 20% of mortgages are now underwater. FICO needs us to believe that we'll be eligible for more debt if we keep our number looking good by not being one of the strategic defaulters.

    But haven't we basically figured out that we don't really want all that debt? Didn't the housing-bubble/mortgage-backed/non-modifying-modification/robo-foreclosure/forged-document/fraud-flash-crash leave a lot of Americans deciding to get off the debt game? So what difference does a FICO score make? Mises makes the point:
    So, even if you had to pay another $10 a month for phone and a little more for insurance the thousands saved each month not feeding an underwater mortgage is still worth it.

    And this is where I scratch my head with the Austrians. Their whole piece seems to be an encouragement for people to up and walk away from their homes and mortgages. They've been recurring this theme for a while now. I don't have a problem with strategic default, per se. But I'm not going to argue for it in an open forum.  It's a decision that shouldn't be made cavalierly. Encouraging anonymous readers toward it just doesn't make sense for a blog representing one of the foundational figures of Austrian Economics. It's the kind of thing the Keyensians would point to as a sign of the unseriousness of the other side.

    But then again, the Keyensians want to inflate away those mortgages. In either case, FICO is an anachronism from the era of personal debt bubbles.

    Wednesday, May 18, 2011

    April FOMC Minutes Word Picture








    Six times in 21 pages, we get everything bad in the economy soft peddled as transitory. Ya know, FOMC... you keep using this word. But I don't think you know what it means. Seriously, they use the word "transitory" sorta like a doctor might say a malignant tumor is "transitory" right before giving you 6 weeks to live.

    If you drink, consider yourself to have found a new drinking game. I've embedded the whole document below, but lifted out the transitory quotes for your convenience.



    "Participants viewed the weakness in first-quarter economic growth as likely to be largely transitory..."


    "Participants revised up their projections for total inflation in 2011, reflecting recent increases in energy and other commodity prices, but they generally anticipated that the recent increase in inflation would be transitory..."


    "Participants generally anticipated that the higher level of overall inflation would be transitory..."


    "Significant increases in energy and other commodity prices had boosted overall inflation, but members expected this increase to be transitory..."


    "Increases in the prices of energy and other commodities have pushed up inflation in recent months. The Committee expects these effects to be transitory...."


    "Participants raised their forecasts for overall inflation this year; however, most expected that the increase would be transitory..."



    Fomc Minutes April

    Schiff on Our Relationship With China

    This morning, I wrote the following in my Wrong Wage post:
    To me, the implication is that as wages rise in the "Chi" half but stagnant in the "merica" half of Chimerica, we will be increasingly paying more for Chinese made goods AND have more demand for those goods by the emerging Chinese middle-class themselves. So from a supply side and the demand side we will have pressures driving up the cost of our goods while US wages stagnate. 

    Now, Peter Schiff is saying something very similar at this point in an interview on RT:

    http://youtu.be/hkEthqUEKA4?t=6m12s

    "People keep saying that China has an export economy. They don't. They have a production economy. The fact that they export their production is their loss. If they simply let the dollar fall and their own currency rise, they would still produce. Except it would be the Chinese that would enjoy the products that are being produced instead of Americans. And the Chinese economy would be much stronger."

    The whole interview is worth watching, so I embedded it here. I think it's notable that we are starting to hear more of the idea that China doesn't need to export to the US to sustain it's economy. This goes against a lot of the conventional wisdom on our relationship to China. Interesting times ahead.






      

    More on Fort Knox

    What we're likely to find if we try to sell the gold in Fort Knox:

    http://youtu.be/Ewy6Jvb6h_k?hd=1&t=3m14s



      

    Debt Limit Solutions by Friz Freleng

    When I see headlines like:
    Selling Gold at Fort Knox Emerges as Next Big Question in Debate on Federal Debt Limit
    I have to wonder if Friz Freleng is now considered the main idea guy at the table?

    And now for something just as serious:




    Hopefully, Yosemite Sam never succeeded in getting that gold out of Fort Knox. Would be a shame if we actually didn't have any to sell.


    You know, this video is sorta ironic if you picture Yosemite Uncle Sam or maybe Yosemite Ben Bernanke.